FICO Takes On Debt To Fund Its Accelerated Stock Repurchase Program – Buyback Wednesdays

We have covered Fair Isaac (FICO) twice before in the context of share repurchases – first in October 2022 and then in July 2025. The company has now returned with another sizable capital-return announcement, authorizing a new $2 billion share repurchase program, representing around 7% of its market cap at announcement. More importantly, it has decided to accelerate nearly three-fourths of this authorization, while funding the entire upfront payment with a new incremental term loan.

I concluded the July 2025 article as follows:

“Looking ahead, Fed rate cuts expected in late 2025 and into 2026, along with a modest decline in mortgage rates, could provide a more favorable backdrop for FICO’s credit-related revenue.

That said, FICO’s ability to navigate its regulatory crossroads will ultimately determine whether it cements its legacy or cedes ground in a market it has long dominated. At this point, I would prefer to hold off on investing until valuation gets back to its long-term averages or the macro environment improves significantly for home buyers.”

A great deal has changed since that article. FICO’s stock lost roughly one-third of its value, while the U.S. mortgage market has begun opening the door to alternative credit-scoring models such as VantageScore 4.0. Against that backdrop, it is worth taking a closer look at how the VantageScore rollout is impacting FICO, and whether management’s aggressive repurchase activity signals confidence or reflects a more defensive response to growing competitive and regulatory pressure. 

Only plus or premium subscribers can access this post. Subscribe today.